Close Menu
MyAppsPlus

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Best Buy Week 3 Black Friday now live: Apple, 50% off TVs, 40% off kitchen, home theater, more

    November 16, 2026

    Helsing backer Plural raises $1.1B to fund Europe’s next moonshots

    November 16, 2026

    Software usability now the focus, say experts

    November 16, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    MyAppsPlusMyAppsPlus
    Monday, November 16
    • Home
    • Breaking Tech
    • Apps & Software
    • AI & Automation
    • Android
    • iPhone & iOS
    • More
      • Reviews
      • How-To Guides
      • Deals & Discounts
      • Shop
    MyAppsPlus
    Home»Reviews»When can we say AI made a scientific discovery?
    Reviews

    When can we say AI made a scientific discovery?

    myappsplusBy myappsplusSeptember 29, 2026025 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Copy Link LinkedIn Tumblr Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Follow Us
    Google News Flipboard
    When can we say AI made a scientific discovery?
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

    Last Wednesday, Anthropic announced that earlier this year it had launched a molecular biology lab, where Claude agents read and conjecture about hard biology problems and human scientists run experiments on what they report. And this AI-powered lab, the company said, had made its first discovery. 

    To understand what Anthropic says its system did, imagine you’re flipping through a library of millions of DNA sequences, amassed as scientists sequence more and more of the living world. One step toward a breakthrough might be finding a peculiar sequence that encodes an interesting enzyme, perhaps. Then you’d need to figure out what that enzyme does and, eventually, how to manipulate it to do something useful.

    What Anthropic says its system of 950 agents found after 21 hours was not a brand-new sequence. The agents instead flagged a repeating pattern surrounding a known enzyme, a particular pattern Anthropic said hadn’t been catalogued before. But if you read through Anthropic’s announcement, which calls this pattern “reminiscent” of what led to the gene-editing technology CRISPR that “has already transformed science and medicine,” it sounds as if this army of agents really found something of note. 

    These claims have angered some biologists. A viral post from one, subsequently endorsed by the chair and CEO of the drugmaker Eli Lilly, said that “finding a weird cluster of genes and repeats is often the easy part. The hard part, and where the real discoveries come from, is figuring out what the system actually does.” The agents helped with some laboratory grunt work, in other words. But a discovery it is not. 

    It’s a reminder that even if AI does something impressive—like finding a pattern in a mass of biological data that would be difficult to perceive with human eyes alone—the result itself may not constitute a breakthrough for science. What is novel for AI may be routine, unsurprising, or simply not that consequential to a biologist.

    Muddying the issue further, Mario Rodríguez Mestre, a biologist at the University of Copenhagen, said over the weekend that his team had already discovered this particular pattern, the New York Times reported. Mestre, who regularly chatted with Claude in his work, wondered whether Anthropic’s team had learned from his conversations. Anthropic denies this, but Mestre says he’s stopping all use of Claude anyway.

    Part of the problem here is that AI companies aren’t presenting their systems simply as tools scientists can use, like microscopes or supercomputers. They’re insisting that the AI systems are making discoveries themselves. To some, that approach is  incompatible with how science actually works, with new knowledge more typically emerging from collaboration and an ever-growing arsenal of tools. 

    It’s also making people more skeptical of genuine progress when it happens. Whittling 200,000 candidates down to a few worth exploring is no small feat; it is legitimate scientific work. The fact that a general-purpose chatbot could do that work is notable, even if humans helped steer it and ultimately ran the experiments. But once the standard is whether Claude itself made a discovery, all that becomes evidence for one side or the other in a debate that has only two answers: breakthrough or bust.

    Once we’re judging AI by whether it has made a discovery, it’s also tempting to shift the goalposts even after it really does seem to notch a win. Earlier this month, OpenAI said its own team agents had cracked a million-dollar problem in mathematics. But a couple of weeks later, nearly every AI skeptic in my feed was sharing an article asking whether it was the math problem that really mattered. 

    To be clear, the piece did not argue that OpenAI’s solution was wrong. Instead, it argued that the particular result may not be the one mathematicians care most about. Throw in the accusation by a mathematician that the models may have used some of his work without credit, and people are left thinking either OpenAI cheated or the solution wasn’t important anyway. Or both.

    That’s part of what concerns Lucas Harrington, the biologist who wrote the post critiquing Anthropic’s announcement. He closed with a suggestion: AI companies, he said, should “set the bar high now, so that when an AI actually discovers a fundamentally new biological mechanism, everyone appreciates how big a deal it is.” But as OpenAI’s Sam Altman and Anthropic’s Dario Amodei race to one-up each other, raising the bar for scientific breakthroughs by AI might be the last thing on their minds.

    Deep Dive

    Artificial intelligence

    A fundamental flaw leaves LLMs strikingly vulnerable to attack

    It makes it easy to trick them into doing things they shouldn’t, such as telling you how to sabotage an aircraft’s navigation system.

    AI’s recursive self-improvement might not come so quickly after all

    AI agents are not yet creative enough to carry out genuinely innovative open-ended AI research, it seems.

    Here’s why AI agents lie and cheat to reach their goals

    The misbehavior is called reward hacking. This is what you need to know.

    These startups are chasing the next big thing in LLMs

    Meet the new kids nipping at the heels of the AI giants.

    Stay connected

    Discover special offers, top stories,
    upcoming events, and more.

    discovery Made Scientific When
    Follow on Google News Follow on Flipboard
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link
    myappsplus
    • Website

    Related Posts

    RedMagic 11S Pro review: Active liquid and fan cooling meets aggressive pricing

    November 16, 2026

    5 best new Netflix movies and shows this week (Nov. 16-22)

    November 16, 2026

    I’ve tested the Fitbit Air, Fitbit Edge, and Fitbit Charge 6 — here is the fitness tracker I’d actually buy with my own money

    November 16, 2026
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    Save on your groceries, gas, and holiday shopping with this $15 BJ’s membership (Reg. $60) 

    November 4, 202629 Views

    Google’s new AI shopping cart tracks deals across stores

    October 25, 202628 Views

    Deal Alert: PS5 DualSense controllers are much cheaper today

    November 11, 202626 Views
    Latest Reviews

    iPhone Ultra is coming, here’s what the final rumors say

    myappsplusSeptember 9, 2026

    LG Smart TVs Caught Recording Audio in Standby and Scanning Your Network

    myappsplusSeptember 9, 2026

    Vikings & Legends Global Announce U.S. Bank Stadium Enhancements for 2026

    myappsplusSeptember 9, 2026
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest tech news from FooBar about tech, design and biz.

    Most Popular

    Vikings & Legends Global Announce U.S. Bank Stadium Enhancements for 2026

    September 9, 20260 Views

    IKEA just launched a Matter-enabled driver that makes your integrated cabinet lights part of your smart home

    September 9, 20260 Views

    Latest Dell Technologies Research Reveals that AI Ambition Outpaces Readiness Across Singapore

    September 9, 20260 Views
    Our Picks

    Best Buy Week 3 Black Friday now live: Apple, 50% off TVs, 40% off kitchen, home theater, more

    November 16, 2026

    Helsing backer Plural raises $1.1B to fund Europe’s next moonshots

    November 16, 2026

    Software usability now the focus, say experts

    November 16, 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest tech news, app updates, AI trends, smartphone reviews, and exclusive deals delivered straight to your inbox.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • About Us
    • Get In Touch
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    © 2026 MyAppsPlus. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.